The Agonizing Dilemma: Periods Inside or Outside Quotes

...

As a writer, have you ever found yourself wondering whether to place the punctuation mark that precedes a menstrual expression inside or outside the quotes? If yes, be rest assured that you’re not alone.

The use of periods when dealing with quotations can be quite an agonizing dilemma, and it has become even more contentious since the era of digital communication. The internet age is characterized by little or no punctuation in social media posts and text messages, where slang and shorthand language prevail. This ambiguity often trickles down into formal writing.

So, should periods go inside or outside quotes? Well, it depends on where you come from, the kind of writing you're doing, and the style guide you follow.

In American English, the period traditionally goes inside the closing quote. For instance:

Mark Twain famously said, If it's your job to eat a frog, it's best to do it first thing in the morning. And if it's your job to eat two frogs, it's best to eat the ugliest one first.

As shown above, the period is located after the word “morning” (within the quotation marks).

On the other hand, in countries such as Canada, the United Kingdom and South Africa use different practices. Here are words from Elizabeth Hamilton:

If you don't study history, you'll never know his story.

A quick insight will demonstrate that the period is located after story, outside of the quotes.

This variation arises due to differences in the respective community's spelling and grammatical changes over time. Nonetheless, formatting quotations have developed small defining features:

- In American English, periods go inside the closing quotation and not outside unrelated to the original quote—but Not vice Versa!

- In Non-American English, periods go outside the ending quotation unless it plays an influential part in the ultimate sentence – Still with me?

Although the distinction between the two styles might seem trivial, following them to the book enhances consistency within the discourse and reduces confusions. It also helps reading-bearing comprehension and reflects allegiance to a specific cultural affiliation or audience in the respective regions using them.

To conclude, the topic of placing intentional periods inside/outside expression marks warrants a conversation amongst writers worldwide. Various resources such as style guides need revisiting to reflect professional opinions ultimately agreed upon globally.

So, the thin little dot that threatens our common sanity- where minds occasionally stray if rules aren't kept- is a punctuation force able to make all kinds of much-needed printed sentences look 'grammatically' fine.

Congratulations! End-to-end article seems appropriate, now we wouldn't allow accidental periods to interrupt even the briefest of messages.


The Agonizing Dilemma: Periods Inside or Outside Quotes

When it comes to punctuation rules, there’s always room for debate, and the placement of periods inside or outside quotation marks is one of the hottest topics in grammarian circles. Some style guides recommend placing the period inside the closing quotation mark, while others say it should go outside. So which rule should you follow? In this article, we’ll take a close look at both sides of the argument to help you make an informed decision.

The American Rule: Periods Inside Quotation Marks

In the US, the most widely-used convention dictates that periods and commas should always be placed inside closing quotation marks, regardless of whether they’re part of the original quote or not. For instance:

“I never drink—said Bela Lugosi—wine.”
“Colorless green ideas sleep furiously” is a sentence composed by Noam Chomsky.

While many people follow this rule without question, some critics have pointed out that it can lead to confusion and inaccuracies in certain contexts.

The British Rule: Periods Outside Quotation Marks (sometimes)

In Great Britain, Canada, Australia, and other commonwealth countries, the rule is often reversed, especially when the quote marks aren’t an exact reproduction of a speaker’s original utterance. Additionally, the British generally reserve double quotes for quoting someone else’s words, using single quotation marks to denote internal quoted material. Here are a couple of examples:

‘She offered me a cold soda but I preferred the warmth of tea’.
In his lecture, Dr. Smith tried to use ‘plopping’ as a technical term.

You’ll notice that in both these cases, the period that ends the sentence is placed outside of the quotation marks. It’s worth noting that in Britain, conventions can vary depending on the context, the mode of publication, and even the individual author’s preferences.

The Technical Rule: Context is Key

Part of the reason why there is such controversy around this issue is that there is no universal solution. Some experts say that the placement of the period should depend on the kind of text and the matter being discussed.

When technical matters and precision are involved, the use of brackets might be the way to go, given that brackets don’t explicitly pertain to the quote.

John Albert Hall had worked on machine scriptwriters [which were] used with computers.

The Copyeditor’s Conundrum

If you’re a copyeditor, during proofreading or polishing up prose, you will constantly be torn between fixing grammar and reading critically. Thus, this can be a source of stress for people in the industry. They struggle with limited time finding a sustainable solution.

Placing the period inside the quotesPlacing the period outside the quotes
Gwyneth Paltrow wrote a cookbook titled It’s All Good. Gwyneth Paltrow wrote a cookbook titled It’s All good.
Playmates is Eminem’s first number-one album.Playmates is Eminem's first number-one album

My Thoughts: Minimum Punctuation or Exact Punctuation?

Personally, I believe that detailed accuracy takes precedence more often, when the article or composition involves technological literature or manual instructions. I think it’s equally important to write quickly under time constraints for easier readability if the information presented isn't that complex. While sending a text message or chatting online, exactness flies out the window, moving through time with minimum punctuation factors refreshing thoughts more effectively.

Conclusion: Follow Your Own Best Interpretation of Punctuation Placement

To wrap things up, there’s no clear-cut answer to the period-inside-quotation-mark dilemma. Ultimately, it’s down to personal preference, professional practice or prescribed mandate depending on the assignment or nature of the written work. Do keep in mind, however, what kind of readers you expect to face-- lay, expert or diverse--especially since the rules for this nuance can ultimately vary quite significantly from one geographical, academic or knowledge context.


Overall, the debate of whether to place periods inside or outside quotation marks can be an agonizing dilemma for many writers. While there are style guides that provide guidance on this issue, ultimately it comes down to personal preference and consistency throughout one's writing. So whether you choose to place your periods inside or outside quotes, just be sure to do so consistently and confidently.

Thank you for taking the time to explore this topic with me. I hope that this blog post has provided some helpful insights and tips for navigating the tricky world of quotation marks and punctuation.

Happy writing!


Sure, here's an example of how you could write the FAQPage in Microdata about The Agonizing Dilemma: Periods Inside or Outside Quotes with mainEntity for a web page:```html

The Agonizing Dilemma: Periods Inside or Outside Quotes

Should periods be inside or outside quotes?

It depends on the style guide you're following. In American English, periods usually go inside quotation marks, while in British English, they can go inside or outside depending on the context.

What about other punctuation marks?

Again, it depends on the style guide. In general, commas and colons usually go inside quotation marks, while semicolons and dashes can go either inside or outside depending on the context.

Why is there so much variation?

The rules for punctuation with quotation marks have evolved over time and vary between different countries and even different publications. It's important to follow the style guide that's appropriate for your context.

```This code defines an FAQPage with three questions and answers about the topic of whether periods should be inside or outside quotation marks. Each question and answer pair is defined as a `mainEntity` within the FAQPage, with the `name` of the question and the `text` of the answer specified using the `itemprop` attribute. The code also uses Microdata to specify the type of each element (e.g. `https://schema.org/Question` for the questions) and to indicate that they are part of the same FAQPage (using the `itemscope` and `itemtype` attributes).